Erdogan's 'Nazi' accusations

Politically motivated provocation

For German-Turkish journalist Cigdem Akyol, Erdogan′s recent ′Nazi′ outbursts can be put down to electioneering. Few taboos remain in his race to win the upcoming referendum. Yet German politicians and the media will be playing into his hands if they overreact. Interview by Laura Doing

Ms. Akyol, what is it like working as a journalist in Istanbul at the moment?

Cigdem Akyol: At the risk of no-one believing me, I haven′t actually had any problems with the Turkish government. Ankara has always issued me with a press card, even if it has sometimes taken a while. I know other German journalists who waited a long time before they were accredited.

It's important to remember – and it's the reality – that Erdogan was elected democratically. Elections were partially not free and certainly not fair, but the man isn't a dictator. That means it's incredibly important not to be led by populist moods and remain factually oriented and cover the topic in a fair way. Of course it's not always easy, given the political situation – journalists are people after all. But one must also take into account the past positive aspects of Erdogan when reporting in order to explain his strength and determination today.

What positive aspects are you thinking of?

Akyol: At one point, he was actually a reformer. Among other things, he expanded women's rights and, for a time, freedom of the press. He led Turkey to the door of the EU and created a middle-class that did not exist before. Thanks to Erdogan, the social systems were improved. These aspects, of course, are things that have contributed hugely to his success. Under Erdogan, there was an economic boom which lasted years, the like of which Turkey had never seen before. But these aspects get ignored because they don't fit into the world picture that many, including the German-language press, have of Erdogan. Instead, everyone agrees he is a born tyrant.

Highly respected investigative journalist Ahmet Sik (photo: picture-alliance)
The muzzling of Turkey′s free press: ten employees of the regime-critical newspaper "Cumhuriyet" alone are currently being held in custody on terrorism charges, not to mention the highly respected investigative journalist Ahmet Sik. Figures relating to the total number of journalists in Turkish prison vary between 80 (Committee to Protect Journalists /CPJ) and more than 140 (P24). Following the attempted coup last summer, more than 170 media outlets and publishing houses were closed down by emergency decree

But what remains of Erdogan the reformer?

Akyol: Not much, to be honest. Those claiming that Erdogan is still on a democratic path or that he's still interested in democratic reform is not living in the same Turkey as I do. The Turkey I live in is a land where people are afraid they will have their passports taken away, be put in jail or lose their jobs because they are critical of the government.

Under President Erdogan, not only was the German-Turkish correspondent of "Die Welt" Deniz Yucel taken into custody, but dozens of Turkish journalists critical of the regime are also sitting behind bars. How did it come to this?

Akyol: Relations between Erdogan and the press were never good. Above all, the Kemalist press, that was once very strong, really gave it to him. He now is taking his revenge. When he was mayor of Istanbul from 1994 to 1998, Erdogan complained that, no matter what he said, the Kemalist press always used it against him. They made fun of him and his impoverished background. They also made fun of his wife and daughter because they wore the hijab. Actually, there was no fair reporting. And while Erdogan himself never valued free word, he had to endure it. But since the failed coup attempt, he has carried out a huge cleansing wave, aimed at everyone who doesn't share his opinion.

As campaign appearances by Turkish ministers were cancelled in Germany, Erdogan spoke of "Nazi practices". Were the Nazi comparisons, in your opinion, serious or just a bit for attention?

Erdogan supporters in Rotterdam (photo: Reuters)
Only half the story: "under Erdogan, there was an economic boom which lasted years, the like of which Turkey had never seen before. But these aspects get ignored because they don't fit into the world picture that many, including the German-language press, have of Erdogan. Instead, everyone agrees he is a born tyrant," writes Akyol

Akyol: His absurd accusations are part of an electoral campaign. The inner unrest relating to the German-Turkish relationship, which is currently increasing in Germany, plays into Erdogan′s hands. He is fishing on the right for his presidential system and he needs the voices of the nationalists – that is why he is playing the nationalist tune once again. The more German politicians and the public react to it, the more he benefits. And that's why he's so hot on it at the moment. One shouldn't actually fall for this scam. My tip: stay objective and polite, yet continue to point the finger.

What issues, in your opinion, beg the most criticism up at the moment?

Akyol: The dismantling of whatever's left of democracy in Turkey. Berlin and Europe must be very clear that no more opposition politicians are to be imprisoned, that the few free, critical journalists in Turkey should not have to fear for their lives, that the rule of law is no longer eluded and that the balance of power is preserved.

What is the situation like for those critical of the government and those active in the cultural scene in Turkey?

Akyol: Criticism is moving underground. There are still people who demonstrate on the street for a "No" vote at the constitutional referendum, but they are usually arrested.

A major topic for those involved in culture and for intellectuals is the question "how can I leave this country?" Are there grants? What country is an option? At the moment, there is no hope for improvement as far as democratic developments in Turkey are concerned.

Interview conducted by Laura Doing

© Deutsche Welle 2017

Cigdem Akyol lives in Istanbul and works as a correspondent for the Austrian news agency APA. She was born in Germany and is of Turkish-Kurdish heritage. Her unauthorised biography on Erdogan was published in 2016.

More on this topic
In submitting this comment, the reader accepts the following terms and conditions: Qantara.de reserves the right to edit or delete comments or not to publish them. This applies in particular to defamatory, racist, personal, or irrelevant comments or comments written in dialects or languages other than English. Comments submitted by readers using fantasy names or intentionally false names will not be published. Qantara.de will not provide information on the telephone. Readers' comments can be found by Google and other search engines.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

Comments for this article: Politically motivated provocation

In "Politically Motivated Provocation", in one question the interviewer Laura Döing states that "more than a dozen Turkish journalists critical of the regime are sitting behind bars."

It is widely reported -- and I have not seen it denied by the Turkish authorities -- that there are over 100 Turkish journalists jailed at present. According to Turkeypurge.com, which lists each one's full name, they number 162 as of March 15, 2017.

No doubt the exact figure is disputed, and the authorities would say most are jailed for alleged terrorist-related offenses, not because they are critical of the government per se.

Nonetheless, I am very disappointed to see this kind of reportage. It appears to me that Ms. Döing is either very poorly informed, or deliberately understating the number in order to make the government crackdown look less severe than it is.

At a time when the media and freedom of speech are under severe threat in Turkey, your readers expect better reporting.

[Passage amended. Thanks for drawing our attention to this translation error. Editor]

Bruce Humes15.03.2017 | 07:56 Uhr