The Lampedusa Tragedy

EU Refugee Policy Is Morally Bankrupt

The EU's interior ministers have discussed refugee policy following the catastrophe off Lampedusa - without any result. They've failed to use a good opportunity for a new, more humane policy, says Ute Schaeffer

Politics and reality sometimes don't have much to do with each other - and that's the case with the refugee catastrophe off the coast of the Italian island Lampedusa. It is an intolerable contradiction: while the number of refugees drowning off the coast of Europe keeps increasing - with more than 270 victims' bodies being pulled from just one boat that caught fire and sank last Thursday (03.10.2013) - politicians sit in air-conditioned conference rooms in Brussels and don't take any action. It's cowardly, it's immoral and it's short-sighted.

Just over 100 kilometers of ocean separate Africa from Lampedusa. That means tomorrow we could wake up to the next catastrophe - and Europe knows it.

Poverty, war and terror

Let's remember that the poverty people are trying to flee is neither self-made nor chosen. It is created by corruption, war and terror. And it is caused by the trade barriers Europe puts up, by our customs duties and our consumption.

Germany's Interior Minister Friedrich (photo: dpa/picture-alliance)
"But nobody dares to push for a new, more responsible and humanitarian EU refugee policy." - Rather than making concrete recommendations, Germany and Germany's Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrichsent up a smoke bomb to distract attention from the real issue, Ute Schaeffer writes

Anyone who has spent time with the Nigerians or Senegalese who later find themselves stranded as "illegals" in Morocco or Libya knows that all they want is to get a foot onto European soil. "Do you think that a single one of us would leave if we saw any kind of perspective for our families at home?" a reporter from Germany was asked. No, hardly anyone would risk the trip.

Looking out for one's own

That's where the discussion has to begin. It's seems almost cynical that the only decision EU ministers were able to make at their meeting was to have the European Union's border agency, Frontex, send its patrol boats further out - and thus well beyond Italian waters. We are behaving as if we need to protect ourselves from criminals or pirates.

We owe these people a conscientious review of our asylum and refugee policies. But no one - not in Italy or Germany - wants a serious discussion about the consequences of this tragedy. German Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich, at least, suggested taking stronger action against the traffickers and improving the situation in African countries. But rather than making concrete recommendations, Germany sent up a smoke bomb to distract attention from the real issue. While dinghies and fishing boats are sinking in the Mediterranean, Friedrich talks about the migration of poverty-stricken people from the EU's poorest member states to countries like Germany. That's the signal that Friedrich wants to send: look at the burden that Germany has to shoulder - we can't take any more!

Coffins for the dead of the Lampedusa tragedy (photo: Reuters)
Intolerable contradiction: "While the number of refugees drowning off the coast of Europe keeps increasing - with more than 270 victims' bodies being pulled from just one boat that caught fire and sank last Thursday (03.10.2013) - politicians sit in air-conditioned conference rooms in Brussels and don't take any action," Schaeffer writes

A declaration of moral bankruptcy

As the EU's largest country, Germany hosted more than 70,000 asylum seeker last year, and thus more than many others. But compared to its population of 80 million, Germany's contribution is only average. Sweden, for example, shoulders its responsibility more boldly, more humanely, more decisively: with 4,625 asylum seekers per million population it leads the field. Meanwhile, Germany, which resists any change to European asylum law, manages just 945 refugees per million. And Italy, which is complaining about its burden right now, hosts just 260 per million.

But nobody dares to push for a new, more responsible and humanitarian EU refugee policy. Faced with the latest catastrophes in Italy or Syria, Germany - the country with the largest economy and the lowest youth unemployment - doesn't even have the generosity of spirit to take in more refugees as a one-off gesture. What an indictment of a wealthy nation!

Ute Schaeffer

© Deutsche Welle 2013

Redaktion: Lewis Gropp/Qantara.de

More on this topic
Print article
Send via mail
Add Comment
In submitting this comment, the reader accepts the following terms and conditions: Qantara.de reserves the right to edit or delete comments or not to publish them. This applies in particular to defamatory, racist, personal, or irrelevant comments or comments written in dialects or languages other than English. Comments submitted by readers using fantasy names or intentionally false names will not be published. Qantara.de will not provide information on the telephone. Readers' comments can be found by Google and other search engines.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.