Arab Reactions to the Pope's Visit
Signs of Hope

Although the Pope's speech in Regensburg still casts its shadow over relations between the Muslim world and the Vatican, Benedict XVI met with a mostly positive reception on his recent visit to Jordan. Details from Fakhri Saleh

Pope Benedict XIV and Jordanian Prince Ghazi Bin Talal (photo: AP)
Dialogue in mutual respect – nevertheless, Prince Ghazi did not gloss over the more awkward points in current relations between Christians and Muslims

​​ Right at the start of his pilgrimage through Jordan, Israel and the West Bank, Pope Benedict XVI warned against misusing religion for political ends.

On the second day of his visit, he held a speech before political and religious dignitaries at the King Hussein Mosque in Amman in which he described religion as a "force for good" that must not be used as a tool for sowing discord and violence in the world. King Abdallah in return welcomed the Pope's visit to the "heartland of Christian and Muslim faith".

Many commentators in the Arab world view Benedict XVI's words as an expression of good will and the intention to improve relations between the Christian and Muslim worlds, strained not least by the Pope's speech in Regensburg in September 2006.

At the time the Pope had quoted a criticism of Islam by Byzantine Emperor Manuel II Palaiologos, insulting and angering millions of Muslims.

Although he did not refer directly to this incident while in Amman, Benedict's call for greater respect both for the values shared by Islam and Christianity as well as for the differences between the two faiths was widely understood as an attempt to build new bridges in a region dominated by conflicts and mistrust.

Protests from the Islamic side

Prince Ghazi bin Mohammed, King Abdallah's supreme advisor in religious issues, admittedly did not fail to recall the sore point. In his address, also held at the King Hussein Mosque, he thanked the Pope for "showing regret about the 2006 speech with which he had hurt the feelings of the Muslims".

Pope Benedict XIV visiting the modern King Hussein Mosque in Amman (photo: AP)
During his visit to the modern King Hussein Mosque in Amman, the head of the Catholic Church was admonished for irritating Muslims all over the world with his 2006 speech in Regensburg

​​ And while Prince Ghazi, who likewise dealt at length with interreligious problems, made only this brief comment on the incident, the politically powerful Muslim Brotherhood demanded an explicit apology from Benedict XVI for his 2006 remarks.

The Islamists in Jordan protested against the Pope's visit, receiving ammunition from the influential Islamic television preacher Yussuf al-Qaradawi. In his Friday sermon in Dauha last week, al-Qaradawi highlighted before a large audience that the Pope had disparaged Islam and the prophets in his Regensburg talk:

"He described Islam as a religion of violence and said that the Prophet Mohammed had made no contribution to the development of humanity."

Al-Qaradawi, who advises the Arab television station al-Jazira in religious matters, expressed his displeasure that the Pope "did not even retract this arbitrary remark when, in the name of the International Islamic Council of Religious Scholars, we requested a correction and an apology".

He referred to the fact that the Council of Religious Scholars had then broken off relations with the Vatican and only intended to resume the dialogue when the demands made at that time had been met.

It was clear from the outset what these reactions expressed: Benedict XVI would have to face up to difficult conditions during his pilgrimage following the path of Christ.

Although the Pope's visit to Jordan was a major success in both political and social terms, and tens of thousands of people – both Christians and Muslims – attended his speeches and sermons, it will not be possible until the end of the week to take stock of the outcome of his trip. The Pope's encounter with the Israelis and Palestinians is likely to be the biggest challenge on his itinerary.

Jordanian Christians welcoming the Pope (photo: AP)
Joy at the Pope's visit, particularly amongst Jordan's Christians: according to the Vatican, some 30,000 Catholics came out to give their religious leader an enthusiastic welcome in Amman

​​ A few days before the venerable guest arrived, Prince El Hassan Bin Talal of Jordan told the Catholic News Service that the Pope's visit was a sign of hope for the Arabs and at the same time could serve to deepen understanding for the interreligious dialogue.

The incident "should not be seen as a passing, calming serene visit that is transient or just another visit to the region, but should rather focus in our minds that we can revive the heritage of trust and good faith".

Reason for confidence?

Can we then expect this visit to produce better mutual understanding between Arabs and Muslims on the one hand and the Western world on the other? After years of bloody conflict following the attacks of 11 September 2001, the prophets of doom invoking a "clash of cultures" really do seem to have grown quieter of late, while the desire for cultural and religious dialogue is once again being plainly expressed.

In the Arab press numerous authors and analysts voiced the hope that the Pope's journey through the deeply torn region offered the prospect for a solution that could bring comprehensive and lasting peace.

Where the point of departure and heart of such a solution might lay was made perfectly clear by King Abdallah as he bid farewell to the high-ranking guest before his flight to Jerusalem. Justice must become a reality, particularly for those suffering "under occupation, deprivation and disrespect".

And despite the pronounced apolitical nature of the Pope's pilgrimage to the Holy Land, his visit to Jordan ended on a blatantly political note when Abdallah expressed his hope for a treaty that would give "the Palestinians their right to freedom and a sovereign state, and the Israelis acceptance and the necessary security".

© Neue Zürcher Zeitung / 2009

Jordanian writer Fakhri Saleh works as editor of the daily paper "Ad-Dustour". He is also head of the Jordanian Society of Literary Critics. In 1997 he received the Palestinian Literary Award and in 2003 the Ghalib Halasa Award for his cultural contribution to criticism and for his translations of English books into Arabic.

The Vatican and Inter-faith Dialogue
Thrown Back by Centuries?
The scandal over the Holocaust denier Richard Williamson and the Society of Saint Pius X has prompted a tidal wave of indignant Catholics to leave the church. Representatives of other religions – like the Muslims – are also beginning to question the pope's willingness for dialogue. By Peter Philipp

Benedict XVI's Statement on Islam and Reason
The Mistakes of the Pope and the Mistakes of the Muslims
Both Pope Benedikt XVI and the Muslims made some mistakes in their recent skirmish. But now it's time to forgive and forget, since Christians and Muslims have much more important challenges ahead, writes media scholar Khaled Hroub

Benedict XVI's Speech on Violence and Faith
Pope Sparks Anger among Muslims
Pope Benedict XVI returned to Rome after a six-day visit to Bavaria. While the trip was mostly personal, remarks he made about Islam have Muslim leaders around the world calling angrily for an apology. Louisa Schaefer and Jane Paulich report