French Armenians plead for Nagorno-Karabakh intervention

French Armenians demonstrate in Paris (photo: Lisa Louis/DW)

The Armenian diaspora in France – the largest in Western Europe – is urging the country to do more to support Yerevan in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. But Paris is, so far, acting with restraint. Lisa Louis reports

By Lisa Louis

Dozens of women and men hurry along a street towards a square behind France's National Assembly in Paris. They are waving Armenia's red, blue and orange flag, or have it draped over their bodies. Some hold up signs that read "Recognise Karabakh", while many chant Hayastan, or Armenia.

The protesters are gathering on a Tuesday afternoon to demand France support Armenia in the conflict with Azerbaijan over the Nagorno-Karabakh region. After all, France harbours Western Europe's biggest Armenian diaspora with up to 600,000 members. But, for now, Paris is showing restraint in its support for the Armenian side – at least when it comes to action.

"This is a cry from the heart," Franck Papazian yells into a microphone, addressing the crowd that has since swelled to several hundred people. He is co-president of the Coordination Committee of Armenian Organisations in France (CCAF), which organised the demonstration in Paris and a dozen others across the country in recent weeks.

"We can't just let this massacre happen – we need peacekeepers in the region!" he pleads. "Please, we are asking you. You won't be able to say afterwards that you didn't know what was happening."

Infographic showing the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh (source: DW) — Are comparisons with the Armenian genocide justified? Azerbaijanis slaughtered more than 20,000 Armenians in Baku in Azerbaijan in September 1918 – under the supervision of the Turkish army. "Both Azerbaijani and Turkish identities are based on a hatred of Armenians, who have been their scapegoats for more than a century and whom they consider their arch enemies," says Mikael Nichanian, a French-Armenian historian and curator at the National Library of France

Turkey "has crossed a red line"

The decades-old conflict over the region erupted afresh in late September. The ethnically Armenian region belongs to Azerbaijan, but has been controlled by Armenians since the 1990s. Several hundred people have been killed in the recent fighting, while tens of thousands have been displaced, according to local officials.

French President Emmanuel Macron early in October accused Turkey of sending hundreds of mercenaries and jihadists to help Azerbaijan. "[Turkey] has crossed a red line – that's unacceptable," he said. He added that, as co-president of the OSCE Minsk Group, he has pleaded for an immediate ceasefire in the region.

The organisation was set up in 1992 to mediate in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and is also co-chaired by the U.S. and Russia. But two ceasefires, negotiated recently by Russia and the OCSE Minsk Group, were almost immediately breached, with both sides accusing each other of violating them first.Mediation efforts by the OSCE Minsk Group seem nevertheless to be France's only plan for now. When asked if other measures, including sanctions against Turkey, were on the table, a source from the Elysee Palace referred back to the OSCE Minsk Group, saying the country was hoping a ceasefire could be established.

France's approach falls short for protesters

That clearly fell short of Talin Mungan's expectations, who travelled with a group of 20 other French Armenians from southern Marseille to join the protest in Paris. "France should immediately cut political and economic ties with Turkey," said the 33 year-old, while wrapped in Armenian flags. "This conflict is the continuation of the Armenian genocide in Turkey in 1915 and 1916, during which the country killed more than 1 million Armenians."

Mungan is referring to when, beginning in 1915, up to 1.5 million Armenians were killed by Ottoman Turks. Many scholars and countries, including the German parliament, have recognised the massacres as genocide. Turkey has repeatedly rejected the term.

At the time, Mungan's grandparents were forced to flee toward Turkey's mountains. They were hidden by Kurds, had to change their names, and pretend to be Muslims. "We can't stand on the sidelines while they massacre our brothers and sisters in Nagorno-Karabakh now," she says.

You may also like: The Armenian genocide – The search for truth and the historical context

A few metres to her left, 40 year-old Samo, who does not want to disclose his last name, silently watches the protesters' speeches. Originally from the western Armenian region of Ararat, he came to live in France with his three children 10 years ago.

"Two dozen of my friends and relatives in Armenia have gone to Nagorno-Karabakh to fight with our compatriots," he admits. "Of course, I fear for them, but I would do the same if I were there right now. We don't have a choice. We have to defend our country – if necessary, with our lives."

"After all, if Azerbaijan wins this conflict, they will certainly not stop there. They will also try to conquer the rest of Armenia," he adds.

But are such fears and comparisons with the mass killings of Armenians justified?

Mikael Nichanian, a French-Armenian historian and curator at the National Library of France, says they are. He believes such a connection could even be made without the current Turkish involvement. "After all, some Azerbaijani politicians participated in the Armenian genocide and were part of the Committee of Union and Progress, the Turkish political organisation which conceived the Armenian genocide."Nichanian added that Azerbaijanis slaughtered more than 20,000 Armenians in Baku in Azerbaijan in September 1918 – under the supervision of the Turkish army. "Both Azerbaijani and Turkish identities are based on a hatred of Armenians, who have been their scapegoats for more than a century and whom they consider their arch enemies."

"That's how these countries unite their citizens in order to maintain their authoritarian regimes," he adds.

French lawmakers urge more support

Against that backdrop, even lawmakers of President Macron's own party, La Republique en Marche (LREM), are pleading for more active support for the Armenians. Some have signed a resolution calling on the government to recognise Nagorno-Karabakh's independence.

Armenian protester Talin Mungan (left) and her cousin wrapped in the Armenian flag in Paris (photo: Lisa Louis/DW) — Emotions among Armenian protesters running high: Talin Mungan travelled from southern Marseille to join the protest in Paris. "France should immediately cut political and economic ties with Turkey," said the 33 year-old. With her grandparents forced to flee towards Turkey's mountains, change their names and pretend to be Muslims during the last century, Mungan adds "We can't stand on the sidelines while they massacre our brothers and sisters in Nagorno-Karabakh now," she says

This includes Anne-Laurence Petel, an LREM member of Parliament. "This is not only about the Caucasus," she explains. "We need to put Turkey's President Recep Erdogan in his place. He's leading expansionist politics, also in the Mediterranean Sea where he's fighting with Greece and Cyprus over gas reserves and maritime rights."

Unchecked, Erdogan could one day invade Cyprus and Greece, she says. "We need to show him that the EU won't have that by setting boundaries now."

Guillaume Kasbarian, another LREM lawmaker, also wants more action. "France's former President Jacques Chirac was strongly pleading in favour of several NATO airstrikes in the Yugoslav war in 1999, which finally forced Yugoslavian President Slobodan Milosevic to back off and prevented an escalation," he asserts. "We need to bare our teeth now, send peacekeepers and impose sanctions – being part of the OSCE Minsk Group just isn't enough."

Protesters at the square behind Parliament remain determined to do their part to force France's hand. "We won't stand back while there's a massacre," Papazian shouts into the microphone. Then, he announces another meeting for a few days' time. "Each one of you should bring along another 10 people, so that our protest grows bigger and bigger," he adds. "Yes!" the crowd cheers back.

"Time is of the essence – tomorrow could be too late," says Papazian.

Lisa Louis