Recourse to the Koran
With its recently-announced withdrawal of hajj subsidies, the Indian government is responding to a 2012 Supreme Court request that the subsidy should be gradually withdrawn over a 10-year period. In their decision, the judges referred not least to the Koran, which only obliges those with the financial means at their disposal to make the pilgrimage. The Supreme Court order that funds saved by the travel subsidy cut should be channelled into education programmes for the socially-disadvantaged Muslim minority is a ground-breaking approach.
Interestingly, reactions to the announcement of the withdrawal of the state hajj subsidy were rather restrained. While the HCI issued a statement calling for implementation of the order to be deferred by one year, thereby waiting until sea routes to Jeddah have been reinstated – a plan that the Saudi authorities have in the meantime approved – representatives of the minority called on the government to make good on its pledge to channel saved funds into education programmes for marginalised Muslim communities.
Cheated in the name of the hajj subsidy?
Criticism is not aimed at the revocation of the subsidy, but at the special status allocated by the Indian government in the pilgrimage programme to the state carrier Air India, a status that the minority believes drives prices up. "There should be an open bidding process for the air tickets," Maulana Khalid Farangi Mahal is quoted as saying in The Times of India. "I'm certain that most airlines will reduce their prices," Mahal continues.
Allem Faizee follows the same train of thought in the online portal ummid.com, where he talks about the "hajj subsidy myth": "The hajj subsidy was never used for the benefit of the pilgrims. The airlines demanded higher ticket prices, the funds for the hajj subsidy served to help the financially-ailing Air India," says the journalist.
Indeed, the flight booking process has little to do with competition. Until further notice, most of the pilgrims from India have no other option but to book their flight to Saudi Arabia with Air India and Saudi Airlines at over-inflated prices.
In a bid to take the wind out of the sails of increasing criticism from the minority, in late February the Indian government announced it would reduce air ticket prices. This decision, says Minister Naqvi, will put an end to the "political and economic exploitation" of the pilgrims.
The new rates that the minister supplied for various embarkation points are indeed less than last year's prices. But it didn't take long for minority group representatives to issue a response, claiming that the prices on offer were considerably higher than in previous years. For example, General Secretary of the "All India Muslim Personal Law Board" (AIMPLB) Maulana Wali Rahmani complained that the Muslims had been cheated in the name of the (hajj) subsidy. The minority representative described the government's communication as "window dressing" and "misleading".
Subsidy withdrawal only for Muslims
The debate surrounding India′s hajj policy throws the tense relationship between the ruling BJP and the country′s Muslim minority into stark relief. The government clearly did not clear these amendments in advance with key organisations and decision-makers within the minority group – let alone involve them in the decision-making process.
The most telling aspect of the Hindu-nationalist government's stance is that the abolition of pilgrim subsidies only affects grants for Muslim pilgrimages. Whereas Narendra Modi's government has gone ahead with the cancellation of the hajj subsidy, public grants for pilgrimages made by the Hindu majority remain in place.
These subsidies are "too numerous to be listed," writes Swaminathan Aiyar in a comment piece. The liberal columnist comes to the conclusion that "a secular state that dispenses with hajj subsidies must of course also prohibit subsidies for pilgrimages of all other religions."
This is – as already stated – a liberal position. A position that falls upon deaf ears within the party of the Indian Prime Minister.
© Qantara.de 2018
Translated from the German by Nina Coon
Dr. Ronald Meinardus is head of the Friedrich Naumann Foundation's regional office for southern Asia in New Delhi