What is new about your approach?

Tamer: It is a new approach to scholarship, because we do not treat the concepts in the respective religions separately but rather simultaneously. Our colleagues discuss the contents with one another in-depth at the conferences. The entire project has a discursive structure. It goes beyond academic analysis of the individual themes to address how we can learn from one another and establish links between how the concept is seen in our own and the two other religions.

What does that mean in concrete terms?

Tamer: Take for example the concept of revelation. When a Christian theologian addresses the term revelation within the framework of the project, he admittedly does so at first from the internal perspective of Christianity, but not without then considering how the term is understood in Judaism and Islam. The same applies conversely to Jewish and Muslim scholars. An example of how important these links are: in the Middle Ages, Jewish thinking made crucial advances within the context of an Arab culture dominated by Islam.

Does this mean that the religions are closer to each other than many people think?

Tamer: Yes and no. They are indeed more closely related than is commonly believed. And yet there are also far-reaching differences that many people are not aware of. In a superficially conducted interreligious dialogue, the impression may arise that we are all much more similar in our beliefs than we once thought, but impressions can be deceptive. It is true in some cases, but not true in many others. We don't merely want to uncover similarities here. We also want to point out differences so that they are recognised and then also accepted. We are after objective insights. That is the best way to respect each other.

Photo montage on the subject of "revelation" in the three monotheistic religions (source: www.kcid.fau.eu)
'Man is the enemy of what he does not know': "We don't merely want to uncover similarities here. We are after objective insights. As a Christian, Muslim, Jew, or non-believer, I need to know how the other person defines herself or himself religiously and acknowledge this otherness. It is not merely a matter of indifferent tolerance. We need a higher level than tolerance, namely recognition and acceptance, without trying to gloss over differences," says Tamer

So the aim is to establish what the differences are – and then?

Tamer: The goal is not only to determine the differences, but also, on the basis of the similarities and differences, to respect the other person in the way he or she wants to be understood. As a Christian, Muslim, Jew, or non-believer, I need to know how the other person defines herself or himself religiously and acknowledge this otherness. It is not merely a matter of indifferent tolerance. We need a higher level than tolerance, namely recognition and acceptance, without trying to gloss over differences. The motto of the project is an ancient Arabic proverb, according to which 'man is the enemy of what he does not know'.

What do you think of the status of interreligious dialogue today?

Tamer: It certainly has a higher profile today than it did a few decades ago. There are numerous dialogue initiatives and forums, which are mainly organised by the religious institutions or by individuals with strong religious convictions, for example Cafe Abraham in Erlangen, initiated by Jewish, Christian and Muslim students. The initiative has now also branched out to other cities. Foundations and policymakers are promoting dialogue. But it is also very important that people of different confessions talk informally with each other about matters of faith, for example during Ramadan, the Muslim month of fasting, or at Christmas time.

But is that enough?

Tamer: We undoubtedly have some catching up to do. I would, however, like to stress at this point that we are not an initiative for interreligious dialogue. We are scholars doing basic research, a kind of archaeology of religious knowledge. As scholars, we want to do everything in our power to attain and disseminate insights on these issues and to contribute in this way to combatting radicalisation and religious fanaticism while fostering social cohesion. In our project, scholarship puts itself at the service of society.

More on this topic
In submitting this comment, the reader accepts the following terms and conditions: Qantara.de reserves the right to edit or delete comments or not to publish them. This applies in particular to defamatory, racist, personal, or irrelevant comments or comments written in dialects or languages other than English. Comments submitted by readers using fantasy names or intentionally false names will not be published. Qantara.de will not provide information on the telephone. Readers' comments can be found by Google and other search engines.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

Comments for this article: From religious tolerance to acceptance

A regular columnist of newageislam.com Mr. Ghulam Ghaus Siddiqi deals with this subject at some length. Here are some excerpts from his article:

"Tolerance in Islam, rightly understood, is patience toward a practice or opinion one disapproves of. This understanding may come as a surprise to many people who interpret tolerance simply as a synonym for the words ‘acceptance’ or ‘agreement’. Islamic tolerance entails disagreement yet a firm moral commitment to the decent treatment of the person with whom one disagrees. So tolerance in Islam can be understood as a patient forbearance against something which is disliked or disapproved of.

"Tolerance in Islam is viewed as a prerequisite essential to maintaining peaceful coexistence. Islamic concept of tolerance can be exercised against a broader spectrum of differences; social, cultural, racial, political, ethnic, religious, and domestic. Islam abhors intolerance causing murder, genocide, violence, religious persecution, injustice and creating disorder in any parts of the globe.
Tolerance in Diversity

Islam recognizes diversity, enumerating it among the signs of Allah for the people of knowledge, as the Quran reads, “And among His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the differences in your languages and colours; indeed in this are signs for people of knowledge” (30:22). This verse asserts that creation of the sky and earth as well as diversity in colours and languages is among the Divine signs. The human beings are divided into many races, having different physical forms and colours—white, black, yellow etc. and this can be easily understood by “the people of knowledge”.
Tolerance Linked with Religious Freedom

"Tolerance is linked with freedom of religion. In this context the oft-quoted verse is of Surah Baqarah (2:256) in which Allah Almighty says, “There is no compulsion at all in Din (Religion). Surely, the guidance has become evidently distinguished from error. So he who rejects false gods and believes in Allah has grasped such a firm handhold that will never loosen. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing” (2:256). This verse establishes a basic Islamic principle upon which the idea of non-compulsion is built, guaranteeing religious freedom for all non-Muslims including Hindus, Christians, Jews, Buddhists and Sikhs etc."

He also deals with these following points in some details;

Tolerance towards Non-Muslims in Islamic Governance

Tolerance in Domestic Sphere

Tolerance in Neighbourhood

Examples of Tolerance in the Life of the Prophet (peace be upon him)

Source: newageislam.com

Kaniz Fatma12.12.2018 | 07:34 Uhr