Islam Criticism in Germany

The Uprising of the Indecent

A riposte from society's middle ground: with his book "The Alarmists", Patrick Bahners wades through the murky depths of criticism of Islam in Germany and warns against a brutalisation of public life. A review by Daniel Bax

​​ It's the same font and layout as "Deutschland schafft sich ab" (Germany Does Away With Itself), only the colours have been deliberately swapped around. Instead of the glaring alarm red with which Thilo Sarrazin's bestseller jumps out at the reader, the cover of Patrick Bahners has been immersed in a calming white, as though signalling the all-clear; only the title, "Die Panikmacher" (The Alarmists) stands out in red lettering.

The editor-in-chief of the arts and culture pages of the FAZ devotes himself to the same wave of excitement upon which Sarrazin ultimately has only been surfing. His book is much more than just response to the nation's most successful scaremonger, as the former Bundesbank director and his theses themselves only make a peripheral appearance. Instead Bahners traces back the prehistory that once paved the way for Sarrazin's 'indecent uprising'.

Contempt of tolerance

"Critics of Islam" in Germany such Necla Kelek, Henryk M. Broder and their supporters imagine themselves to be at war with Islam, which for them overrides the necessity for democratic procedures. Bahners takes great pleasure in dissecting their vocabulary, their shrill warnings against "appeasement" and "giving in", their contempt of tolerance or their insistence on a "leading culture" and "Judeo-Christian tradition".

Visitors at the Sehitlik Mosque in Berlin (photo: Markus Schreiber/AP)
First disintegrate, then integrate: According to some critics of Islam in Germany, all integration policies are in any case in vain – as long as Muslims do not renounce their faith

​​Bahners refers to the contradictions of a double standard that allows a Bundesbank director to step out of line, but does not allow a Muslim teacher to wear a headscarf. And he shows how topoi previously derived from right-wing extremist propaganda have permeated public discourse.

For example when Ralph Giordano of all people complains about the historic "pressure of guilt" that apparently makes it impossible for Germans to face up to the "true" integration problem that is Islam. Or the idea that debate must now take place "without taboos", used by Kristina Schröder for example as a code for disseminating prejudiced views.

The logic of suspicion

Bahners makes it clear that the anti-Islamic polemics popularised by Necla Kelek, Henryk M. Broder or Ralph Giordano are actually a highly specific form of "religious criticism", which itself exhibits religious characteristics and tends toward apocalyptic thought. The opponent of Islam presents his view as the absolute truth – and therefore views all dialogue as a betrayal. On the one hand he would like to see an omnipotent state that, like a punitive god, puts all divergent behaviour – in this case Muslim behaviour – in its place.

At the same time, and this is the neo-liberal aspect, he views the welfare state as largely obsolete. Because in his view all integration policies are in any case in vain, as long as Muslims do not renounce their faith, he regards political efforts in this regard to be counterproductive.

Necla Kelek (photo: © Wolfgang Borrs)
Embodiment ofthe ideal of a "secular Muslim" who has drawn a line under her religion – Islam critic Necla Kelek

​​Bahners sketches in detail the bizarre genesis of the "Muslim test" in Baden-Württemberg, as well as the row over the headscarf ban for teachers, which he regards as a grave mistake, because here the logic of suspicion won for the first time, resulting in discriminatory laws. "The headscarf debate has set in motion a brutalisation of public life, which has been further accelerated in the debates over mosques and Sarrazin's theories," he writes.

He devotes a further chapter to Necla Kelek, a revered figure among those critical of Islam in Germany. In spite of shocking argumentative contradictions and claims that have been refuted many times ("One in every two Turkish marriages is arranged!" "More and more Muslim parents are taking their daughters out of swimming and sports lessons!") she continues to be feted by media and politics because for many Germans, she embodies the ideal of a "secular Muslim" who has drawn a line under her religion.

Shabby accusations

Bahners' book is long overdue. One major criticism would be that he is unfortunately likely to scare off many readers with his headstrong, and at times unwieldy style and the unstructured and anecdotal way that he flits from quote to quote.

Patrick Bahners (source: C. H. Beck)
Rubs his eyes in amazement at the sudden amnesia of many regarding the history and erroneous ways of Christianity in Germany: Catholic and intellectual Patrick Bahners

​​Of course, it must also be taken into consideration that this book is the work of a conservative. As a devotee of bourgeois virtues Bahners is pained by the brutalisation of the debate and the shabbiness of the accusations that are being aimed against Muslims. And as a Catholic, he rubs his eyes in amazement at the sudden amnesia of many regarding the history and erroneous ways of Christianity in Germany. He wonders where it is all heading, after all, the postulates of those who oppose Islam leave room for only one conclusion: "Muslims out".

An assessment of the situation in neighbouring countries would certainly have helped. In Austria, the FPÖ has long campaigned using quotes from catchphrase creators such as Alice Schwarzer or Henryk M. Broder, and in the Netherlands, rightwing populist Geert Wilders capitalises on the political legacy of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, demanding a ban on Muslim immigration and a ban on headscarves in public places. The fear of Islam that Bahners describes is not just a German phenomenon, and the key participants in the debate are to a certain degree interchangeable.

It is also a shame that Bahners only mentions the responsibility of the media in passing. A blind spot? After all, the arts and culture pages of the FAZ are among the most favoured places for Necla Kelek, Thilo Sarrazin and other opponents of Islam to emit their opinions, for the most part without commentary and unchallenged. It would have been nice to see a derisory riposte from Bahners a long time ago.

Daniel Bax

© Die tageszeitung/Daniel Bax/ 2011

Translated from the German by Nina Coon

Editor: Lewis Gropp/

Patrick Bahners: "Die Panikmacher. Die deutsche Angst vor dem Islam". C. H. Beck Verlag, München 2011.

Integration in Germany
"The Best Form of Lead Culture Is Called Democracy"
The Germans have many years of experience with integration that they could draw on – but it has vanished from their collective memory. This is one reason why German integration and immigration policy is driven more by fear and concerns about domestic security than by tolerance and respect. By Heribert Prantl

Fresh Dispute over Islam
Why the German Media are Courting the Anti-Islam Movement
If discussions on the cultural pages of German newspapers in spring 2010 were representative of German opinion, then we must assume that around half the German population comprehend Islam as a threat. Does the negative attitude towards Islam testify to vigilance or to prejudice? Stefan Weidner looks into the matter

Integration in Germany
Better Than Its Reputation
The German media are inclined to present people from an immigrant background mostly as school failures, petty criminals, welfare recipients, Islamists or thugs. But the current annual report compiled by the Committee of Experts on Integration and Immigration gives surprisingly good marks when it comes to integration in Germany. Holger Moos reports

Interview with Germany's Interior Minister Schäuble
"We Must Give the Muslims Time"
How can one bring about peace among the various religions? An interview with the German interior minister and protestant Wolfgang Schäuble on the integration of Muslims into the value system of the German constitution. Interview: Patrick Bahners

Related Topics