Swiss legal expert to rule on Muslim pupils' handshake exemption


A Swiss legal expert will decide on the validity of a controversial ruling that allows male Muslim students to avoid shaking hands with female teachers for religious reasons, an official said on Tuesday.  The decision reached by a school in Switzerland's northern municipality of Therwil sought to reach a compromise with two male students, aged 14 and 15 and their families, but ended up causing uproar and fierce public debate over the limits of religious freedom.

"We have asked for an expert opinion from our legal service," said Deborah Murith, spokeswoman for the education department in the canton of Basel-Country, where Therwil is located.

The two students informed the school that a Swiss custom of pupils shaking teachers' hands violated their faith if the teacher is a woman. To avoid approving the de facto discrimination of female teachers, the school decided to exempt the boys from shaking hands with any of their teachers, regardless of sex.

That ruling – made independently by the school without involvement of the cantonal authorities or municipal officials – triggered an outcry across Switzerland.

Justice Minister Simonetta Sommaruga insisted on Swiss public television Monday that "shaking hands is part of our culture", in remarks echoed by other senior officials and public figures.

Murith told journalists that the case was "not simple" and that Basel was now trying "to find a balance between religious liberty, the right to education and the legally enshrined equality between men and women." She said the compromise reached by the school could serve as a "provisional measure", while the legal expert prepares guidance, without specifying when that decision would be made.

The head of the Therwil school system, Christine Akeret, told Swiss media that she plans to abide by the expert ruling, but voiced frustration that she had not previously been given instruction from higher authorities on the matter.

Murith agreed that "there is currently a gap in the current regulation on this subject. "That is why we have asked for an expert legal opinion," she said.

Switzerland's population of eight million people includes an estimated 350,000 Muslims. Previous similar disputes have centred on Muslim parents who demanded that their daughters be exempt from swimming lessons, a case that led to the parents being fined.

Muslim families have however secured victories in court against schools which sought to ban the full face veil.    (AFP)

Visit's dossier on Islam in Europe


In submitting this comment, the reader accepts the following terms and conditions: reserves the right to edit or delete comments or not to publish them. This applies in particular to defamatory, racist, personal, or irrelevant comments or comments written in dialects or languages other than English. Comments submitted by readers using fantasy names or intentionally false names will not be published. will not provide information on the telephone. Readers' comments can be found by Google and other search engines.