Tolerance and religious freedom in France

Fighting radical Islam with lessons in secularism

The French government wants to send imams and non-Muslim civil servants to classes in secularism and religious freedom in an attempt to prevent home-grown extremism and promote tolerance. Elizabeth Bryant reports from Lyon on a programme that is paving the way

Sunlight slants across a classroom at the Catholic University of Lyon, where the Bible dominates a recent lecture. The subject may seem unsurprising in this ancient city, which was once a bastion of French Catholicism, but the dozen or so people jotting down notes are not theology students. One young woman wears a headscarf. A man sports the beard of a devout Muslim. Others are non-Muslim civil servants working for the local government.

All are enrolled in a programme on secularism and religious freedom that is jointly run by two Lyon universities and the city's Grand Mosque. They're the unlikely foot soldiers of a national campaign for greater religious tolerance that seeks to help shape a moderate, Western-oriented "Islam a la Francaise."

The drive has taken on new urgency since January's terrorist attacks in Paris and the departure of hundreds of French youths to join jihadist movements in the Middle East. The Socialist government has responded with a raft of new measures to fight home-grown extremism. Among them: plans to enrol hundreds of imams and other key Muslim figures in civics training programmes and to make them mandatory for chaplains working in prisons and the military.

But Lyon's programme has broader ambitions, as it reaches out to include government officials in the training. "If things are going to change, they need to change in all directions," says Michel Younes, co-director of the initiative at Lyon's Catholic University. "That means not only training imams about secularity, but also civil servants, because the subject of religion in public spaces has almost become a taboo."

"Living together has to be more than an idea," he adds. "It's being able to be together, think together, exchange ideas together."

A lesson in secularism and religious freedom at the University of Lyon (photo: DW/E. Bryant)
A lesson in secularism and religious freedom at the University of Lyon. According to Elizabeth Bryant, "the 24-week programme includes classes on law, religion and how French principles of secularity are applied to daily life"

Imported imams

France has always had an uneasy relationship with Islam, the country's second biggest religion. Clashes over issues like the wearing of headscarves in public schools – which is now banned – to Halal butchering practices and religious burial grounds have deepened divisions and misunderstandings between the state and the five million-strong Muslim community.

It doesn't help that many imams are foreigners; few French Muslims are interested in a job that is so poorly paid. So the clerics are imported from North Africa and Turkey, countries that often finance their salaries and even the construction of the French mosques they preach from. Many only have a sketchy idea of the country's laws and customs. Some cannot even speak French.

"These imported imams are not efficient," says Hacene Taibi, who heads the Muslim teaching institute at Lyon's Great Mosque and helps run the civics training programme. The mosque's own imam, who is Tunisian, now says prayers in both Arabic and French. "Sometimes the faithful here won't even accept imams who don't preach in French," Taibi says. "This training programme helps them understand how this country functions."

The 24-week programme includes classes on law, religion and how French principles of secularity are applied to daily life. The students visit churches, mosques and synagogues. At the end of the training, they receive certificates in the "Understanding of Secularity." Since it began in 2012, it has trained dozens of imams and other key Muslim figures.

They include Koranic teachers like Baian, who declined to give her last name for privacy reasons. "I was asked to take this programme so I could speak to others about secularism," she says. "Here in France, we have to all live together."

The Grand Mosque in Lyon (photo: picture-alliance/Godong)
In dialogue: two Lyon universities and the city's Grand Mosque are running a programme on secularism and religious freedom. It is part of a national campaign to promote greater religious tolerance across the country

Reaching the right people?

Karim Ghanemi, vice president of a local mosque association, said he was surprised to learn that laws governing secularism also granted space for religious expression – a realisation that could help counter the pull of radical Islam. "Muslims here feel oppressed, when in fact freedom to worship exists," he says. "It helps remove prejudice and misunderstanding."

French authorities are not just worried about cultural misunderstandings. The number of mosques controlled by fundamentalist Salafi preachers has doubled from 44 to 89 over the past four years, according to a recent article in "Le Figaro" newspaper, which cites government statistics. France has also expelled a number of radical imams over the years.

But Muslim leaders argue that the majority of imams and other influential figures are working in exactly the opposite direction."Go to Friday prayers, everyone speaks out against extremism," says Taibi, of the Lyon mosque. "We do the same work with our teaching programmes in the mosque."

Whether they can influence a new generation of French, who are becoming radicalised on the Internet, is a matter of debate. And it ultimately raises questions about the limits of the civics training.

"These people are very far from the mosque," says Tareq Oubrou, rector of the Bordeaux mosque, referring to the new Islamists. "They don't have beards, they don't wear hijabs, they don't even do their five prayers regularly. They're just delinquents. You can't expect imams to resolve problems created by society."

More diversity, more debate

Michel Younes (photo: DW/E. Bryant)
"If things are going to change, they need to change in all directions. That means not only training imams about secularity, but also civil servants," says Michel Younes, co-director of the initiative at Lyon's Catholic University (pictured here)

But other observers believe any action by the government is better than none at all. "Because public opinion will never forgive it for not trying to save these children," said criminologist Alain Bauer. "Nor will the parents who find their kids have left a small Post-it on the fridge saying, 'I'm going to jihad, and I'm happy and I love you.' Because that's what's happening at the moment."

Younes of the Catholic University acknowledges the limits of the training in fighting extremism. "But we have to start somewhere," he said. "As more Muslims are trained, they can spread another message. That's what's important: to introduce diversity and debate. Without that, we can't confront radicalism on the net."

Still, the Lyon programme appears to be meeting another key objective. At the Bible class, student Laurent Jacquelin, a senior official for the regional prefecture, described shared meals and conversations with his Muslim classmates. "It's a chance to strengthen what brings us together, our mutual humanity," he says. "And that helps build mutual respect."

Elizabeth Bryant

© Deutsche Welle 2015

More on this topic
In submitting this comment, the reader accepts the following terms and conditions: reserves the right to edit or delete comments or not to publish them. This applies in particular to defamatory, racist, personal, or irrelevant comments or comments written in dialects or languages other than English. Comments submitted by readers using fantasy names or intentionally false names will not be published. will not provide information on the telephone. Readers' comments can be found by Google and other search engines.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.