Power Struggle Hits Literature
Ertugrul Günay is a friendly man with a frequent smile, far removed from clichés of fervent Islamists. The Turkish minister of culture and tourism sees himself as an aide for his country’s literature at this year’s Frankfurt Book Fair from 15 to 19 October, where Turkey is the Guest of Honour.
But for some critics, the 60-year-old minister is the spearhead of an Islamic attempt to co-opt the fair. Shortly before the most important cultural event for Turkey in years, the country is looking on as the bitter political power struggle between the Kemalists and the religious conservatives takes centre stage in literature and the book fair.
Under the motto "Turkey in all its colours", some 350 Turkish writers, most prominently the Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk, and representatives of more than 100 Turkish publishers are expected in Frankfurt in October.
Accusation of political instrumentalisation
One group of authors, however, will not be joining them. They accuse Minister Günay and the government under Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan of exploiting the book fair for their own political ideas. These writers are calling on their colleagues to boycott the fair.
Turkish Kemalists, who trace their ideas back to Atatürk, the founder of modern Turkey, and regard Erdogan as an Islamist, have long since suspected the prime minister of trying to transform Turkey into a moderate Islamic state.
In their opinion, Turkey is to be made into a country no longer governed under laicist principles, but by a soft-boiled form of Islamism, which not only the government supports, but also – they allege – the USA, in the hope of creating a model state for the future of the entire Near and Middle East.
The boycotters are not deterred by the fact that Erdogan and Minister Günay, who only joined the governing religious conservative party AKP last year after decades in the Kemalist party CHP, reject these accusations.
The government intends to change the secular character of Turkey using the moderate Islam model, says the Istanbul-based literary critic Füsun Akatli, a spokeswoman for the boycott movement, so far made up of about two dozen writers.
Akatli and her fellow activists see the government’s announcement that Turkish culture will be presented in all its many facets at Frankfurt as a trap. In the guise of diversity, they maintain, Islamist authors and ideas will be presented to the world as an equal part of Turkish culture.
But, says Akatli, writers who speak out in favour of allowing headscarves on campus for female students, for example, are only a tiny minority that should not play a role in the presentation of Turkey at a major fair like Frankfurt.
Günay defended his stance on Turkish television, pointing out that the government sees its task solely as providing the infrastructure for the book fair, at a cost of six million euro. He ruled out any form of ideological influence, dismissing the boycott movement as a "small group".
The Turkish organisational committee in Frankfurt also reacted to the boycott with incomprehension. The book fair is not a government-run event but a meeting for publishers, said Müge Gürsoy Sökmen, a publisher and co-chair of the committee. The Turkish government has had no influence over the programme, she added, which includes some 250 events from readings to discussions to theatre performances.
Nor was the government involved in deciding which Turkish writers were invited to Frankfurt and which were not, Sökmen told the Turkish internet portal "bianet".
It seems the boycotters are having little success with Turkish authors. The novelist Ahmet Ümit, for example, said that he is not a friend of the AKP either, but there is no point in boycotting the book fair in protest against Erdogan’s party. There has been no news of a wave of Turkish writers cancelling their appearances, two weeks before the fair kicks off.
Not a minor programme issue
Yet Minister Günay hasn’t quite succeeded in erasing all accusations of political influence. This may well be his own fault, at least to some extent. He ensured that the book fair’s opening gala will feature an oratorio by the Turkish composer Adnan Saygun, translated into German.
The piece is based around 13 religious poems by Yunus Emre, a 14th-century Turkish folk poet. Originally, the gala was planned to showcase an oratorio by the young pianist and composer Fazil Say, about the communist poet Nazim Hikmet.
At first glance a minor programme issue, this was a highly political decision for Fazil Say. The musician is one of the Turkish government’s Kemalist critics, and has already publicly voiced thoughts of emigration due to Erdogan’s alleged attempts to Islamise the country.
It is no coincidence that Günay had his piece taken off the programme for the opening gala, said Say – his music was "censored". Say has also come out in favour of the book fair boycott: he won’t be coming to Frankfurt now, he announced recently in the Hamburger Abendblatt newspaper.
© Qantara.de 2008
Translated from the German by Katy Derbyshire
Arab Literature in Translation
Listen to What the Arab World Has to Say
In a world in which translations of literary works are getting more and more important for the understanding of other cultures, there are distinct gaps in most European book markets when it comes to know creative writing from other countries. This is particularly true for the literature of the Arab World, writes Peter Ripken
Frankfurt Book Fair
Will the Arab League Miss Its Chance?
When the Arab League was announced as the guest of honor at the 2004Frankfurt Book Fair, reactions were mixed. The very concept of a wholesale presentation for an entire, diverse cultural sphere struck some as questionable. By Hassan Dawud
Frankfurt Book Fair 2004
A Great Opportunity for Arab Publishers
As head of the "American University in Cairo Press", Werner Mark Linz is also the publisher of Nobel prize laureate Nagib Machfus. In this interview he talks about the current situation on the Arab publishing and literary scene and preparations for the Guest of Honour presentation at the Frankfurt Book Fair in October.