"The status quo has to go"
Jordanʹs streets have witnessed widespread popular protests over the past week, sparked by proposed amendments to the income tax law, which would have increased the number of people required to pay tax. As people chanted in the streets, different voices, from analysts to government officials, blamed the refugees and regional circumstances for the deteriorating economic situation in Jordan, sending a message to the outside world that Jordan should not be left alone to deal with them.
As it happened, I was in the midst of the crowds of demonstrators, as a citizen and a journalist, at the Fourth Circle near the cabinet office building, and what I heard was very different.
There, I met representatives of the "marginalised", the shrinking “middle class", concerned citizens, and those who have belatedly woken up to the impact of the last strike and decided to speak out. We were all gathered in that spot. No-one called for the repatriation of the refugees.
"Weʹre not slaves"
I didnʹt hear a word about the refugees. Instead I heard cries such as "freedom", "weʹre not slaves" and "government of thieves". The protesters were demanding the same rights as their predecessors had done in the April 1989 demonstrations. Beginning in the southern city of Maʹan, those protests led to the return of democracy in Jordan after decades of martial law.
Following these most recent protests, the government of Prime Minister Hani al-Mulqi resigned. Omar al-Razzaz has been appointed to form the new government. He served as minister of education in the previous government and boasts a good number of supporters who would like to see him succeed.
Despite al-Razzaz having "clean hands" and a solid reputation, he has not been readily accepted by the people. Even before his appointment had been confirmed, they had begun chanting: "Oh Minister Razzaz,....the status quo has to go." It bodes well that nominal changes no longer fool Jordanians, who long for the day when the prime minister is elected and accountable to the people for everything.
Hardly free to choose
But there is no doubt that achieving these rights is still a long way off, especially given the flimsy arguments put forward by the official spokesmen and those who benefit from the present situation. Whenever you say anything, they immediately accuse you of wanting to sacrifice "security and public order", or of wanting to drag the country down into the awful wars that have destroyed Syria, Iraq and many other countries!
I confess that I value security and public order more than anything. I am well aware from my work with refugees, directly or otherwise, just how precious the blessing of security is. The dozens of refugees Iʹve met hate many things about their lives in Jordan, but they are ever grateful for this blessing. Some of them said that they came to Amman and were amazed to see people going out onto the streets without fearing for their lives. Others said that the most important difference here was that they could sleep uninterrupted for hours at night.
This is a godsend which we value highly, but we must not be short-sighted. All those who are hungry and oppressed threaten this security – and they are vulnerable in the face of imbalances in the status quo. The rising crime rates in Jordanian society confirm this hypothesis. Thereʹs a huge disparity between the governorates and Amman, not to mention within the capital itself. All this threatens public order.
Breeding grounds for extremism
All those people who call in to Jordanʹs daytime complaints programmes on TV and radio are a latent threat to public order. Combined with the lack of democracy and representation, poverty and unemployment, which has reached 18.4% according to official statistics, presage a bleak future indeed.
Havenʹt experts on extremism repeatedly pointed out that it is born out of poverty and hardship and that Jordan has exported more than a thousand fighters to terrorist organisations?
Didnʹt prominent researchers Muhammad Abu Rumman and Musa Shteiwi affirm in their recently published book "Sociology of Extremism and Terrorism in Jordan" that the threat has not ceased with the fall of Islamic State, as we might have hoped. On the contrary, it persists and will grow if we donʹt destroy its breeding grounds.
I say this because neither is the situation in Jordan sustainable, nor does it serve anyoneʹs interests. Letʹs hope that the Jordanian state has taken this on board. Those who call themselves "loyalists" need to stop bullying peaceful activists, whether such pressure is with the stateʹs approval or on their own initiative. There can be no excuse for intimidating the latter through relatives and employers in an attempt to dissuade them from making legitimate demands.
Sadly, we thought we had covered this ground back in 2011. Alas, we are regurgitating all the same platitudes for the umpteenth time.....Letʹs hope we donʹt go backwards this time!
© Qantara.de 2018
Translated from the Arabic by Chris Somes-Charlton
Lina Shannak is a Jordanian journalist who writes for various Arabic and international news sites such as 7iber, Raseef22, al-Araby al-Jadid and al-Jazeera English.